Our latest poll has closed and, in attempting to find out who you thought was Jim's best signing of the summer, it has perhaps given a greater indication of where you think he went wrong.
Kevin Lisbie has proven to be the most popular signing so far, but its those further down the list, or not on it at all, that are more revealing.
Lisbies early goals for Town appear to have gone some way to winning fans over as he tops the poll as Magiltons best summer signing. With the goals having dried up in more recent times, however, he perhaps would not feature so highly at this precise moment in time.
However, its in second place where more of a story is told. By a comfortable margin, many thought that the player Jim has yet to sign was likely to be the best signing. Perhaps indicating that fans felt that Jims summer signings to that point had not been particularly exciting, or that the player that he needed above all else had yet to be signed. Certainly, with regard to the left-midfield position, the latter would certainly appear to be the case as it continues to be a problem position.
It could be argued that the player in question was Jon Stead. Doubtless, nobody would have agreed at the time, but if a similar vote were to take place right now, Stead would be in with a very good chance of winning it.
Richard Wright was fairly well placed, although perhaps not highly enough for a player who was signed with high expectations to finally fill a problem position. With recent mistakes, the voting looks to have been about right however; generally well thought of, but by no means a resounding success.
The most notable amongst the remaining has to be new Team Captain, Gareth McAuley. Of only 6 available option, McAuley collected just over 5% of the vote, which is by no means an endorsement of either Jims judgement or the impact of the player himself.
The full results:
Who has been Jims best signing this summer?
Kevin Lisbie 29%
The one we havent signed yet 26%
Richard Wright 18%
Owen Garvan (having signed his new contract) 12%
Pim Balkestein 10%
Gareth McAuley 5%
Showing posts with label Rivals- Poll. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rivals- Poll. Show all posts
Tuesday, 30 September 2008
Wednesday, 30 July 2008
Poll Results: Released Players
We asked you which of the players released by the club, or transfer-listed, at the end of the season you would most like to see stay. Two players were far ahead of any others. It seems that most of you would rather we didnt let Billy Clarke leave, whilst many will be sad that Sito has left. Read the full results....
Whilst fans hold most affection for the academy product who turns out to be a star, similarly the academy products are, understandably, the ones we least want to see fail and move on.
In part, its also because it feels as if Billy Clarke is a case of unfulfilled potential. He has shown in flashes that he has the ability and that he might be able to make it at this level. Quick and sharp, with excellent movement, he just needs a bit of confidence and a run of games. Whether he gets that or not remains to be seen, but at this moment hes still here so the dream lives on....
Sito was second, which again is no real surprise. Of all the players on the list, Sito was the only one who had played regularly in the first team over the last few months of the season. He has also been a very popular player in his three seasons at the club. It seems that he is just not quite up to the required level in the eyes of the management, something that most fans quietly acknowledge. He moves on with warm wishes.
Dan Harding came third, which is again not entirely surprising. Harding was a popular player during his first season, where he grew into the left back role, gaining confidence as the weeks past. A drop in performances seemed to erode that confidence very quickly and see him out of the first team picture. Given his former success, its not surprising that many fans would like to see him stay and get another chance.
Gavin Williams was perhaps the surprise, coming fourth. This is inevitably a result of the unquestionable ability that the player posesses, a real case of unfulfilled potential. His fitness and general level of form were more dominant factors however, and so he has moved on.
Gary Roberts lagged some way further behind, perhaps an indication that the majority of fans had already concluded that he wasnt going to make it. He should have a greater impact at Huddersfield.
Completing the list are the two older players, Legwinski and Wilnis, both of whom have graced this level but look unlikely to play there again as they look to retirement, and Matt Richards, the player that I think most fans have forgotten is still actually employed by Ipswich Town.
Full Results-
If one of the released/for sale players could stay, which one?
Billy Clarke 275 votes
Sito 260
Harding 81
Williams 68
Roberts 42
Wilnis 37
Legwinski 37
Richards 16
Whilst fans hold most affection for the academy product who turns out to be a star, similarly the academy products are, understandably, the ones we least want to see fail and move on.
In part, its also because it feels as if Billy Clarke is a case of unfulfilled potential. He has shown in flashes that he has the ability and that he might be able to make it at this level. Quick and sharp, with excellent movement, he just needs a bit of confidence and a run of games. Whether he gets that or not remains to be seen, but at this moment hes still here so the dream lives on....
Sito was second, which again is no real surprise. Of all the players on the list, Sito was the only one who had played regularly in the first team over the last few months of the season. He has also been a very popular player in his three seasons at the club. It seems that he is just not quite up to the required level in the eyes of the management, something that most fans quietly acknowledge. He moves on with warm wishes.
Dan Harding came third, which is again not entirely surprising. Harding was a popular player during his first season, where he grew into the left back role, gaining confidence as the weeks past. A drop in performances seemed to erode that confidence very quickly and see him out of the first team picture. Given his former success, its not surprising that many fans would like to see him stay and get another chance.
Gavin Williams was perhaps the surprise, coming fourth. This is inevitably a result of the unquestionable ability that the player posesses, a real case of unfulfilled potential. His fitness and general level of form were more dominant factors however, and so he has moved on.
Gary Roberts lagged some way further behind, perhaps an indication that the majority of fans had already concluded that he wasnt going to make it. He should have a greater impact at Huddersfield.
Completing the list are the two older players, Legwinski and Wilnis, both of whom have graced this level but look unlikely to play there again as they look to retirement, and Matt Richards, the player that I think most fans have forgotten is still actually employed by Ipswich Town.
Full Results-
If one of the released/for sale players could stay, which one?
Billy Clarke 275 votes
Sito 260
Harding 81
Williams 68
Roberts 42
Wilnis 37
Legwinski 37
Richards 16
Monday, 24 March 2008
Poll Results: Goal of the Season so Far
No surprises really in our goal of the season so far poll. Pablos outstanding effort against Charlton Athletic was the clear winner and looks unlikely to be beaten between now and the end of the season. See Full Results.
Whilst Pablos effort is the stand-out goal so far, the 2nd choice was much harder to make.
Jon Walters attempt to break the net against Bristol City narrowly wins out over Alan Lees effort at Burnley (surely the best team goal of the season?) and Sylvain Legwinskis fine volley against QPR (proving that class is permanent).
Since the poll was put up, Shumis goal against Blackpool would probably now be a contender also.
Interesting to note that of the nine goals to choose from, all four goals scored away from home made the top 5. Perhaps an indication that, with our away form somewhat lacking, it required moments of outstanding individual ability to score away from home. Whereas all the goals scored at home were good team goals.
Its also seems a long time since Gary Roberts goal against Sheffield Wednesday on the opening day of the season. At the time, it felt like it would be one of the goals of the season. Since then, the goal, and the player, have faded from memory.
1. Counago v. Charlton
2. Walters (2nd) v. Bristol City
3. Lee v. Burnley
4. Legwinski v. QPR
5. Quinn v. Wednesday
6. Wright v. West Brom
7. Miller v. Preston
8. Roberts v. Wednesday
9. Haynes v. Wolves 10
Whilst Pablos effort is the stand-out goal so far, the 2nd choice was much harder to make.
Jon Walters attempt to break the net against Bristol City narrowly wins out over Alan Lees effort at Burnley (surely the best team goal of the season?) and Sylvain Legwinskis fine volley against QPR (proving that class is permanent).
Since the poll was put up, Shumis goal against Blackpool would probably now be a contender also.
Interesting to note that of the nine goals to choose from, all four goals scored away from home made the top 5. Perhaps an indication that, with our away form somewhat lacking, it required moments of outstanding individual ability to score away from home. Whereas all the goals scored at home were good team goals.
Its also seems a long time since Gary Roberts goal against Sheffield Wednesday on the opening day of the season. At the time, it felt like it would be one of the goals of the season. Since then, the goal, and the player, have faded from memory.
1. Counago v. Charlton
2. Walters (2nd) v. Bristol City
3. Lee v. Burnley
4. Legwinski v. QPR
5. Quinn v. Wednesday
6. Wright v. West Brom
7. Miller v. Preston
8. Roberts v. Wednesday
9. Haynes v. Wolves 10
Monday, 31 December 2007
Half Season Player of the Year Poll
According to our Poll, Jon Walters is unsurprisingly your choice as the player of the season so far.
Walters received 274 votes, beating Pablo Counago on 175. Little surprises there at all, with Walters having a fantastic season so far and Pablo seemingly improving by the week. Owen Garvan came third, a good performance even though I suspect most would agree he hasnt reached top form yet this season.
However, its fair to say that the last month has probably seen Pablo as our outstanding performer, so it will be curious to see how their form develops over the remainder of the season. Certainly, Walters form looks like it could be largely dependent on how successful Jim Magilton is in securing a new left midfielder in the transfer market, allowing Walters to return to his more accustomed right-midfield role.
The full results were as follows:
Walters 274
Counago 175
Garvan 33
DeVos 16
Wright 14
Lee 8
Walters received 274 votes, beating Pablo Counago on 175. Little surprises there at all, with Walters having a fantastic season so far and Pablo seemingly improving by the week. Owen Garvan came third, a good performance even though I suspect most would agree he hasnt reached top form yet this season.
However, its fair to say that the last month has probably seen Pablo as our outstanding performer, so it will be curious to see how their form develops over the remainder of the season. Certainly, Walters form looks like it could be largely dependent on how successful Jim Magilton is in securing a new left midfielder in the transfer market, allowing Walters to return to his more accustomed right-midfield role.
The full results were as follows:
Walters 274
Counago 175
Garvan 33
DeVos 16
Wright 14
Lee 8
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)